American Girl Dolls Vs. Our Generation (What’s The Difference?) 

Last updated on September 14th, 2022 at 09:44 pm

*This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Last updated on September 14th, 2022 at 09:44 pm

Dolls are undoubtedly a classic gift for the kids, regardless of the occasion. Throughout the past few decades, there has been an increase in the range of options for dolls. 

There isn’t a one size fits all solution when it comes to choosing dolls for kids, but the 18-inch dolls have certainly been a hit among a lot of children. 

The American Girl dolls have been an industry leader when it comes to giving children a massive range of options for dolls and their accessories. However, Our Generation has been coming close when it comes to high-quality dolls as well. 

If you are looking for the right doll for a child near you, these two brand names would certainly be on your list.  

With such a wide range of options by both brands, it can get difficult to choose between American Girl and Our Generation dolls.

The best way to decide is to do an American Girl doll vs. Our Generation doll comparison. 

American Girl dolls come with a hefty price tag, but they also offer children the highest quality and a unique buying experience for them as well. On the other hand, while the quality might not be as high, Our Generation dolls are more affordable and offer a decent range of options as well. 

To help you decide, I have highlighted some of the differences and similarities of both brands in the rest of this article. So keep reading to learn more about what the real differences are between the two. 

Differences Between American Girl And Our Generation Dolls

Each brand has its own set of features that make them an excellent choice for kids, but certain factors of one brand do outweigh the other. 

Here are the significant differences between the dolls offered by both brands:


Both of these brands offer 18-inch-tall dolls with similar bodies. However, there are slight differences in the measurement. 

The Our Generation dolls have smaller shoulders when compared to American Girl dolls. 

The American Girl dolls do have a longer torso than the Our Generation dolls. The legs also have a different cut for both dolls to make it easier for the torso to hold.


The major difference between these two doll brands is the price. The American Girl dolls are much more expensive than Our Generation dolls, which are 1/4th of their price. That is a massive price difference!

You are certainly paying for the brand name when buying American Girl dolls, but it does provide you with higher quality and a better experience.

Range of Options

If you are hoping to find a doll that looks more like your child, then American Girl is the best option. They have a wide range of dolls available in varying skin colors, hair colors, and eye colors. 

They even offer dolls with a historical reference or dolls of other famous celebrities.  


While there are slight differences in the measurement of these dolls, the overall quality of the American Girl dolls is higher than the Our Generation doll, but not by too much. 

The feel of the Our Generation dolls is not as dense as the feel of the American Girl dolls.

The mechanics of the head, arms, and legs of American Girl dolls are better in terms of mobility as compared to that of Our Generation dolls. The eyes of Our Generation dolls also shut and open more loudly than the American Girl.


The hair of any doll has always been an issue throughout the years. However, when it comes to these two brands, the hair of American Girl dolls is much better in quality and for brushing than the Our Generation dolls.

This might not be a big deal for the parents, but being able to brush the hair of their doll is significant for the kids. No one wants their doll hair to become a bird’s nest.

Brand Appeal

Purchasing from a high-end brand, like the American Girl, certainly comes with its perks. This brand offers a complete experience to kids who come in to buy the dolls of their choice. 

The buying experience offered by this brand is above and beyond anything offered by Our Generation dolls. 

The American Girl store has coordinating setups, with accessories, clothes, and a variety of dolls beautifully organized. The kids can get the ears of their dolls pierced, get their hair done, and so much more. 

 A store like this is certainly a dream come true for many kids. Even most adults get excited in this store.

Factors That Make American Girl and Our Generation Dolls Similar

Aside from the many differences between the American Girl and Our Generation Dolls, there are many similarities too that go beyond their 18-inch height. 

Here are some of them:


Both brands offer a wide range of accessories with dolls, as well as furniture. The American Girl has a wider range, but it is also more expensive than the accessories and furniture offered by Our Generation. 

The possible accessories that can be purchased include clothes, shoes, cars, sunglasses, jewelry, phone, purse, and so much more.

While Our Generation offers a similar range of accessories and furniture, their price is much more reasonable than the American Girl brand. 

Since the dolls from both brands are identical in height and similar in size, the accessories can be interchanged if you wish. This means your kids can enjoy changing and dressing their dolls if they have both.

Personal Touches 

Both of these brands use specific names for all their dolls that give them a personal touch. Some even come with a booklet that talks more about the doll. 

This makes it fun for the kids when they are playing. The dolls based on historical characters also share relevant facts about the person that adds a learning perspective to their playtime. 

Wrapping Up

Both the American Girl and Our Generation brands offer an excellent range of dolls for your children to enjoy. They have their differences and similarities, but at the end of the day, it is what your kids love the most that will be best for you. 

However, if you are looking for a budget-friendly doll for your kids, Our Generation dolls are the right choice. 

But, if you are looking for high-quality dolls and a wholly unique experience, then the American Girl dolls are the best choice.

You can even go for the American Girl Brand for the doll and Our Generation for the accessories to give your kids a wonderful experience while also saving a little bit of money. 

Last updated on September 14th, 2022 at 09:44 pm

Matthew R

Hi, My name is Matt and I am all about toys! When trying to find accurate information online about toys I was finding it difficult so I decided to make this site.

Recent Posts